Cell phone restrictions are becoming more common in US schools as districts try to address rising mental health concerns among students. Many schools now ban or limit cell phone use, with some even prohibiting students from carrying phones on campus. The policies aim to reduce distractions and improve student well-being.
According to the Washington Post, the Los Angeles school district voted to ban cell phone use back in June. States like Indiana, Louisiana, South Carolina, and Florida are also limiting cell phone access in schools, while New York, Virginia, and other states are still considering banning them altogether.
Videos by VICE
Clark County, Nevada, is even requiring students to store their cell phones in pouches for the day. That seems a bit intense, if you ask me.
Now, it’s pretty obvious that just because cell phone restrictions are in place doesn’t mean students will adhere to them. I mean, have you ever tried to tell a middle- or high-schooler what to do? Nevertheless, many districts are reportedly considering penalties as severe as exclusion from extracurricular activities and suspension.
The intent behind this initiative is to eliminate distractions, encourage in-person communication and connection, and improve the mental health of students across the country—goals we can all get behind. But is banning cell phones altogether the answer?
“Knowing what we know, something must be done,” said Alberto M. Carvalho, superintendent of the Los Angeles Unified School District. “Smartphones and the content students access relentlessly 24/7 are distracting kids from learning and eroding their mental health.”
Maybe there’s some kind of weird future middle ground with the rise of minimalist phones. At least then, people wouldn’t be tempted to check their notifications in math class.
Or maybe the solution is more like this old, more reasonable suggestion: “Instead of banning cell phones, why don’t we work to create an engaging classroom environment where students don’t feel the need to text their friends during class?”
